Psychwatch New Zealand – An Introduction

By psychwatchnz

Greetings,

My name is Steve Taylor, and I am the Convener of Psychwatch New Zealand. I am a double degree qualified Counsellor, Supervisor, and Mediator who works in Private Practice in Auckland, New Zealand (www.24-7.org.nz). I have worked in the helping profession for 12 years, and have been in private practice for the last 6 years.

In my industry, I have become incensed at seeing New Zealand mental health staff, counsellors, and care workers not being held accountable for negligent and grossly incompetent practice, such practice at times resulting in the unnecessary and ultimately preventable deaths of vulnerable people, leading to heartbroken and desperate families.

On 2/6/08, I appeared on the TV1 “Breakfast” show, commenting on the woefully inadequate mental health services that exist in New Zealand at state funded level:

http://tvnz.co.nz/view/video_popup_windows_skin/1884428

Since the show aired, and as a result of the overwhelmingly positive response I have had to me speaking out about this issue, I have decided to set up Psychwatch New Zealand as a “name and shame” site, listing specific cases and mental health staff whose service to consumers and their families breaches the Health & Disability Code of Practice.

The Office of the Health & Disability Commissioner has recently released a statement informing the New Zealand public that healthcare providers who provide care that breaches the Health and Disability Code of Practice will be named and shamed:

http://www.hdc.org.nz/publications/namingprovidersconsultation/introduction

Unfortunately, the Health & Disability Commissioner will only name an individual after three breaches of the HDC Code of Practice. Psychwatch New Zealand believes that this decision leaves far too much room for damage to be done by any healthcare provider, who can simply slip back into the anonymity of a “Healthcare Team”.

Psychwatch New Zealand is seen as a supplementary service to consumers and families who are currently fighting to either secure reasonable access to mental health services, or those consumers and families who may be fighting for justice against what can seem at times as a system almost impregnable to meaningful accountability.

Consumers and families of New Zealand mental health services who wish to list their specific experience on Psychwatch New Zealand are now invited to submit their story by email to 24-7@maxnet.co.nz.

While Psychwatch New Zealand will be publishing the names of the mental health service provider, the nature of the mental health intervention received, and the names and roles of the staff involved in the care plan, Psychwatch NZ recommends that the names of specific consumers who receive or who have received mental health services remains anonymous.

If the Ministry of Health or the Health & Disability Commissioner wish to follow up a specific case profiled on this site, Psychwatch New Zealand will first secure your consent to release your contact details, and then will invite either the Ministry or the Commissioner to contact you directly.

Steve Taylor,

Convener,

Psychwatch New Zealand

12 Responses to “Psychwatch New Zealand – An Introduction”

  1. Karyn Says:

    Good job! I too am completely flabbergasted at the god-like mentality of some Health-Care professioanls in this country, although I am sure they exist all over the world, New Zealand definately has a general lack of accountability in the Health-care sector.

    Regards,
    Karyn.

  2. Tina Rowe Says:

    Excellent idea!!! Thank You in advance.

  3. Chris Lynch Says:

    Hi there I work at NewstalkZB could you please call me on 09 366 0466

    Thanks

  4. Claire Says:

    This is exactly what New Zealand Healthcare need!!
    Why should medical practitioners not be held accountable?
    Why should the public not have a true and accurate picture of the competence of the medical provider they are to be engaging with / taking professional advice from or investing their money in?

    Would be good to see this site extended to showcase the work, recommendations, professional misconduct, and harm the dangerous dishonest plastic surgeons that grace st marks rd remuera auckland are guilty of yet advertise themselves as leading medical specialists.

  5. Bronwyn Says:

    I work in Health care and I too am shocked at the “God like mentality” that exists.
    Good on you for having the balls to make a stand!!

  6. Pete Rose Says:

    Hi Steve, as an ex inmate of the infamous Lake Alice adolescent unit
    I shall be watching your site with interest.

    I had hoped to actually report a couple of mental health professionals
    here, but that does not appear to be the case as it’s just another
    wordpress blog

    For all of the publicity your blog has recieved in the media
    not one online media article actually provides a direct link to it,
    that tells us that the ‘powers that be’ disapprove.

    Psychiatry is a bit of a ’sacred cow’ and those that rule from behind the scenes don’t take kindly to folks speaking out against it.

    Respect to you sir for having the courage to make a stand

  7. psychwatchnz Says:

    Hi Pete,

    Consumers or families who wish to forward their stories may email them to 24-7@maxnet.co.nz. I will be posting some terms and conditions of publication soon, as stories that people want released into the public domain have already started arriving.

    Steve Taylor

  8. Once Committed Says:

    You know, as someone who has used services myself, I cant help but wonder whether this is the right approach. Bad mental health stories are hardly uncommon in the media.

    Is there the slightest possibility that you might instead push people away from accessing services when they most need them? What about the fact that by in large, the many many stories of the use of any health service, mental health are positive as well? Why not promote and discuss the positive aspects, the people who are making a difference day in and day out without much acknowledgement? Why not give examples of what clinicians and support staff should aspire to?

    It would seem that your approach is rather, excuse the pun, depressive.

  9. Rose Says:

    Good on you. Mental Health Services destroyed my family when they allowed a mentally ill family member to make false rape allegations against our Dad. This happens such alot especially when a patient has had Repressed Memory Therapy or other terribly dubious treatments

  10. BammBamm Says:

    There are lots of bad things in psych services.
    There are lots of bad doctors.
    There are lots of dead patients.
    No one can ask where or why.

    Lawyers cover it all.

    Time to start drug testing ALL doctors. Test them now, and remove them.
    46 % of doctors have drug and alcohol problems.

    If they can’t run their own lives, abide by medical oaths, and stay off illegal or illicit drugs – THEN THEY SHOULDN’T BE THERE!

  11. Carole Marfell Says:

    I am a Victim of Crime(s) I provide support and advocacy for other Victims of Crime. Also ANY after-care/support needed. Victim-Link-Services is independent to any affiliated groups. This is the only service provided in NZ. I believe it takes another victim of crime to know of anothers’ journey. “A little Compassion Goes A Long Way”

  12. Heartburn Home Remedy Says:

    After reading through this article, I just feel that I really need more info. Could you share some resources ?

Leave a Reply